| 5/17/2025 | New York Mets (3)
New York Yankees (2) | New York Mets | 5 | | Money Line: | New York Mets | Winner | | Spread: | No Pick | - | | Total: | No Pick | - |
|
| 5/17/2025 | Detroit Tigers (1)
Toronto Blue Jays (2) | Toronto Blue Jays | 3 | | Money Line: | Toronto Blue Jays | Winner | | Spread: | No Pick | - | | Total: | No Pick | - |
|
| 5/17/2025 | Atlanta Braves (6)
Boston Red Sox (7) | Boston Red Sox | 13 | | Money Line: | Boston Red Sox | Winner | | Spread: | No Pick | - | | Total: | No Pick | - |
|
| 5/17/2025 | Washington Nationals (10)
Baltimore Orioles (6) | Washington Nationals | 16 | | Money Line: | Baltimore Orioles | Loser | | Spread: | No Pick | - | | Total: | No Pick | - |
|
| 5/17/2025 | Minnesota Twins (7)
Milwaukee Brewers (0) | Minnesota Twins | 7 | | Money Line: | Minnesota Twins | Winner | | Spread: | No Pick | - | | Total: | No Pick | - |
|
